Enoch Burke news

2023 - 2 - 16

Post cover
Image courtesy of "The Irish Times"

Enoch Burke tells court school 'is not entitled to be more welcoming ... (The Irish Times)

'Mr Burke does not listen,' barrister for Co Westmeath school tells appeal court.

In other submissions, Mr Burke said he was already “a condemned man” when the school went to the High Court and the judges of the High Court had upheld that “condemnation”. Despite that, Mr Burke is repeating the invalidity argument in this appeal, he said. Mr Connaughton said his side agreed with what the court had said earlier this week concerning whether a person in contempt of court orders can apply to the court for relief. This was very serious when “a demand to participate in transgenderism” had been made and he was drawing up submissions “on the side of my prison bed”. Mr Burke complained one of the judgments he is appealing extended to 19 lines and contained “jumbled” sentences. Asked by Ms Justice Maíre Whelan how he would address the student, he said he would not address them “in a way that is unlawful”.

Post cover
Image courtesy of "Newstalk"

Enoch Burke accuses court of putting gun to his head as appeal ... (Newstalk)

Enoch Burke's High Court appeal against orders to stay away from Wilson's Hospital School in Co Westmeath is underway.

Despite orders to stay away from the school from which he has since been dismissed, Mr Burke has continued to defy the order. Enoch Burke’s appeal against orders of the High Court, one of which was to stay away from Wilson’s Hospital School in Co Westmeath, got underway this morning. Earlier this week, Enoch Burke was told it shouldn’t be assumed that an appeal would be entertained from someone still in contempt of court.

Post cover
Image courtesy of "BreakingNews.ie"

Court of Appeal hears Enoch Burke's challenge to injunction (BreakingNews.ie)

Mr Burke has been fined €700 each day he has attended Wilson's Hospital School in Co Westmeath, in breach of a court order.

The legal team for Wilson’s Hospital School told the court that “Mr Burke does not listen”. “(The email said) ‘It is expected of you’. In his appeal to the court, Mr Burke said he could not accept “transgenderism” due to his Christian beliefs, after teachers at the school were asked to address a student by “a new name and the ‘they’ pronoun”. Mr Birmingham said the court would hear Mr Burke’s appeal against the decisions of High Court judges Ms Justice Siobhan Stack and Mr Justice Max Barrett, “notwithstanding the fact that we were unimpressed” that Mr Burke did not indicate whether he would continue to be in contempt of court. President of the Court of Appeal, Justice George Birmingham, said it was “a matter of some importance” whether Mr Burke intended to continue his “ongoing” contempt by attending the school despite a High Court order against it. On Thursday morning, the three-panel court said it had concerns about hearing an appeal if Mr Burke intended to continue to be in contempt, but decided to continue to hear the case.

Post cover
Image courtesy of "RTE.ie"

Court of Appeal will proceed with Burke challenge (RTE.ie)

The Court of Appeal will proceed with an appeal by Enoch Burke against High Court orders, including an injunction to stay away from Wilson's Hospital School ...

Mr Justice Birmingham said a situation where the person appealing had not obeyed court orders and said they would not be obeying them and yet was seeking orders the other side had to obey would be a very imbalanced situation indeed and one which the court could not countenance. On Monday, the Court of Appeal sat briefly where Mr Justice Birmingham told Mr Burke that the judges wanted to flag with him that it should not be assumed an appeal would be entertained by the court from someone who was still in contempt. President of the Court of Appeal Mr Justice George Birmingham said the court sees difficulty in embarking on an appeal in a situation where there is ongoing disobedience with court orders, which include staying away from the school.

Post cover
Image courtesy of "thejournal.ie"

Burke tells court: 'The only thing State is bound to honour by the ... (thejournal.ie)

The court today heard the appeal of Enoch Burke against an injunction taken against him by Wilson's Hospital School.

“(The email said) ‘It is expected of you’. In his appeal to the court, Burke said he could not accept “transgenderism” due to his Christian beliefs, after teachers at the school were asked to address a student by “a new name and the ‘they’ pronoun”. Birmingham said the court would hear Burke’s appeal against the decisions of High Court judges Ms Justice Siobhan Stack and Mr Justice Max Barrett, “notwithstanding the fact that we were unimpressed” that Burke did not indicate whether he would continue to be in contempt of court. President of the Court of Appeal, Justice George Birmingham, said it was “a matter of some importance” whether Burke intended to continue his “ongoing” contempt by attending the school despite a High Court order against it. The court has heard Burke argue that he has breached “no valid” court order, and also that the order was “manifestly unconstitutional and unlawful”. TEACHER ENOCH BURKE has told the Court of Appeal that “the only thing the State is bound to honour by the constitution is religion”.

Post cover
Image courtesy of "The Irish News"

Irish court hears trans row schoolteacher's appeal against school ... (The Irish News)

Enoch Burke has been seen on the grounds of Wilson's Hospital School, Co Westmeath, over several days despite a court order banning him from doing so.

“(The email said) ‘It is expected of you'. When asked by Justice John Edwards whether there was a more appropriate setting than at a religious service “to make a public spectacle and to confront the principal in the way in which she was confronted”, Mr Burke responded that “under no circumstances could it be portrayed as gross misconduct”. Mr Burke also argued that the constitution “guarantees” a right to “respect and honour” religion. Mr Burke responded that a demand had been “forcefully and clearly made” in the email and that that was his “immediate concern”. In his appeal to the court, Mr Burke said he could not accept “transgenderism” due to his Christian beliefs, after teachers at the school were asked to address a student by “a new name and the ‘they' pronoun”. President of the Court of Appeal, Justice George Birmingham, said it was “a matter of some importance” whether Mr Burke intended to continue his “ongoing” contempt by attending the school despite a High Court order against it.

Post cover
Image courtesy of "The Irish Times"

Enoch Burke tells court school 'is not entitled to be more welcoming ... (The Irish Times)

Classroom Central digest: Enoch Burke appeal; summer school participation; fee-charging schools; record-matching H1s achieved following appeal; the Merchant ...

Norma Foley’s half-baked reform of the Leaving Cert ought to be abandoned: It looks like Norma Foley’s “early win” senior cycle reform may now be untenable. Anecdotally, many of those who made it to college are not doing so well. It is the timeless, humane question asked by Shakespeare in the Merchant of Venice, the most popular play on the London stage in 1596. “She was such a home bird,” she says. Hello and welcome to this edition of the Classroom Central digest! Merchant of Venice offers important lessons on how we treat the outsider: How do we treat the outsider?

Post cover
Image courtesy of "Dundalk Democrat"

Court hears trans row schoolteacher Enoch Burke's appeal against ... (Dundalk Democrat)

A court has heard the appeal of Irish schoolteacher Enoch Burke against an injunction taken against him by a Co Westmeath school, despite concerns about his ...

“(The email said) ‘It is expected of you’. The court also heard there was a school midterm break this week; Mr Burke did not indicate to the court whether he intended to continue to be in contempt of court by attending Wilson’s Hospital School. In his appeal to the court, Mr Burke said he could not accept “transgenderism” due to his Christian beliefs, after teachers at the school were asked to address a student by “a new name and the ‘they’ pronoun”. Mr Birmingham said the court would hear Mr Burke’s appeal against the decisions of High Court judges Ms Justice Siobhan Stack and Mr Justice Max Barrett, “notwithstanding the fact that we were unimpressed” that Mr Burke did not indicate whether he would continue to be in contempt of court. President of the Court of Appeal, Justice George Birmingham, said it was “a matter of some importance” whether Mr Burke intended to continue his “ongoing” contempt by attending the school despite a High Court order against it. The court has heard Mr Burke argue that he has breached “no valid” court order, and also that the order was “manifestly unconstitutional and unlawful”.

Post cover
Image courtesy of "Belfast Newsletter"

Enoch Burke - Irish court hears trans row schoolteacher's appeal ... (Belfast Newsletter)

A court has heard the appeal of Irish schoolteacher Enoch Burke against an injunction taken against him by a Co Westmeath school, despite concerns about his ...

"(The email said) 'It is expected of you'. The court also heard there was a school midterm break this week; Mr Burke did not indicate to the court whether he intended to continue to be in contempt of court by attending Wilson's Hospital School. In his appeal to the court, Mr Burke said he could not accept "transgenderism" due to his Christian beliefs, after teachers at the school were asked to address a student by "a new name and the 'they' pronoun". Mr Birmingham said the court would hear Mr Burke's appeal against the decisions of High Court judges Ms Justice Siobhan Stack and Mr Justice Max Barrett, "notwithstanding the fact that we were unimpressed" that Mr Burke did not indicate whether he would continue to be in contempt of court. On Thursday morning, the three-panel court said it had concerns about hearing an appeal if Mr Burke intended to continue to be in contempt, but decided to continue to hear the case. The court has heard Mr Burke argue that he has breached "no valid" court order, and also that the order was "manifestly unconstitutional and unlawful".

Post cover
Image courtesy of "Jersey Evening Post"

Irish court hears trans row schoolteacher's appeal against school ... (Jersey Evening Post)

A court has heard the appeal of Irish schoolteacher Enoch Burke against an injunction taken against him by a Co Westmeath school, despite concerns about his ...

The court also heard there was a school midterm break this week; Mr Burke did not indicate to the court whether he intended to continue to be in contempt of court by attending Wilson’s Hospital School. “(The email said) ‘It is expected of you’. President of the Court of Appeal, Justice George Birmingham, said it was “a matter of some importance” whether Mr Burke intended to continue his “ongoing” contempt by attending the school despite a High Court order against it.

Post cover
Image courtesy of "Irish Examiner"

Court reserves judgement on Enoch Burke's appeal against school ... (Irish Examiner)

Mr Burke claims that the orders, which underpin a finding that he was in contempt of court resulting in his incarceration for 108 days, are unconstitutional, ...

He asked if the court was going to make any findings on decisions made by other judges, Ms Justice Eileen Roberts and Mrs Justice Conor Dignam, in relation to the dispute. Mr Justice Birmingham said it was not up to the court to advise Mr Burke, but said that the court would consider any relevant argument made by the teacher. He said that was not a relevant consideration and that the case before the court was all about the "unlawful and unconstitutional," demand made on him by the school. In his submissions Mr Burke re-iterated that the school's direction to him was to refer to a student, who he accepted was not in his classes but was somebody that he may have had interactions with in the school, by a different name and by the pronoun they. Mr Burke, counsel said, has appealed that decision. His appeal centres around a number of orders made by a judge of the High Court last September, in a case he claims centres around his objection to the school's direction to refer to a student at the Co Westmeath school by a different name using the pronoun 'they.'

Post cover
Image courtesy of "Irish Mirror"

Enoch Burke's dispute with school over gender issue continues as ... (Irish Mirror)

His appeal centres around a number of orders made by judge of the High Court last September, in a case he claims centres around his objection to the ...

Mr Justice Birmingham also on number of occasions invited Mr Burke to "get on" with his appeal. It is the school's case counsel said that Mr Burke had acted "in a highly objectionable manner," and it was entitled to take the steps it did. In his submissions Mr Burke re-iterated that the school's direction to him to refer to a student, who he accepted was not in his classes but was somebody that he may have had interactions with in the school, by a different name and by the pronoun they. He said that was not a relevant consideration and that the case before the court was all about the "unlawful and unconstitutional," demand made on him by the school. Mr Burke, counsel said, has appealed that decision. Mr Justice Birmingham said it was not up to the court to advise Mr Burke, but said that the court would consider any relevant argument made by the teacher. After a short deliberation the CoA said it would consider the appeal but was limiting it to Mr Burke's appeal against Ms Justice Stack's decision to grant the school a temporary injunction, and Mr Justice Barrett's decision to keep the injunction in place pending the final outcome of the High Court action. There then followed exchanges between Mr Justice Birmingham and Mr Burke over what the teacher as to what the court was going to consider as part of his appeal. Mr Justice Birmingham said the teacher had sought to call upon the jurisdiction of the court and expected others to comply with any orders in his favour it may decide to make. Mr Justice Birmingham said that any future failure to comply with the orders until a point that a court decided they should be set aside was something the CoA would have to take into consideration, or indeed was something that could have resulted in the court not hearing the appeal. At the outset of Thursday's hearing, the CoA said it was willing to proceed to hear a "limited" appeal after the Co Mayo teacher refused to give the court any undertakings that he would comply with the orders to stay away from the school while the appeal was under consideration. His appeal centres around a number of orders made by judge of the High Court last September, in a case he claims centres around his objection to the school's direction to refer to a student at the Co Westmeath school by a different name using pronoun 'they.'

Post cover
Image courtesy of "BreakingNews.ie"

Enoch Burke argues school asked him to 'engage in falsehood' (BreakingNews.ie)

The Court of Appeal said it would have 'great difficulty' with someone before the court who is 'picking and choosing' what legal orders to obey.

That’s what I was being asked to do,” he said. “It’s a jumbled sentence, judge, and that’s being generous. to engage in a falsehood with my lips. He was released before Christmas. Mr Burke argued that the injunctions issued against him preventing him from attending Wilson’s Hospital School were not valid and that the orders issued by the High Court were “manifestly unconstitutional and unlawful”. In his appeal to the court on Thursday, Mr Burke said he could not accept “transgenderism” due to his Christian beliefs, after teachers at the school were asked to address a student by “a new name and the ‘they’ pronoun”.

Explore the last week