Commentary: Oscar nominee 'Tár' brought conducting into the spotlight. That's not good for classical music. Cate Blanchett stars as Lydia Tár in director Todd ...
But somewhere along the line in the making of “Tár,” love was left behind on the cutting room floor. The music advisor for “Tár,” John Mauceri, served as an assistant to Bernstein and is the founding conductor of the Hollywood Bowl Orchestra, which he led from 1990 to 2006. It was music-making as matter of life and death from a beloved conductor, who announced that he had a life-threatening brain tumor well over a year before the film was released. Even if Tár’s tasteless remark may have been meant to show us more about her than MTT (and there is no way to know what was intended in a film that delights in enigma), it exemplifies the film’s petty tone. A wealth of knowing chatter, gossip and the goings-on in the orchestra is meant to add to the film’s realism. At a rehearsal, Tár smugly likens trying to conduct the players to standing on the podium with “a four-thirty-three trying to sell a car without an engine.” A possible translation is that she is stuck with meaningless silence, a callback to John Cage’s silent piece, “4’33”,” and even then the players are so hapless they can produce no juice. After making a bundle, he dropped out of business and hired top conductors with whom he obsessively studied the symphony until he could half conduct it. These comedies made plenty of fun of the classical music world at the time, parodying its exaggerated glamour but with a layer of warmth. Even Yul Brynner in the goofy 1960 film “Once More, With Feeling!” is curiously believable because of the expert studio orchestra soundtrack. On the other hand, Cate Blanchett, in her role as Lydia Tár, attempts to show what it really takes to conduct an orchestra, let alone reveal what it might require and feel like for a women to become the music director of the Berlin Philharmonic, the most desirable job in the profession. Nominated for best picture in 1996, “Shine” delivered an Oscar to Geoffrey Rush for best actor and led to making pianist David Helfgott’s unfortunate recording of “Rach 3” a bestseller. The idea of creating a horror film around orchestra life does have a certain ghoulish charm.
Following claims of misogyny, the debate about Tár – the film starring Cate Blachett as Lydia Tár, a famous, fictional and sexually predatory classical ...
Then she is hurt by them or tires of them and discards them. The young, the old: we all need to listen. Perhaps she can only tolerate a little of seeing needs that can’t be met. There was a tendency to walk in step, to not break ranks, to move forward in a literal phalanx in a new form of sisterliness that could, at times, stifle. She has a softness, yes, but we sense it is towards those who don’t have what she has. If we take Tár as emblematic of her generation, we may better understand her character and the costs she faced. She is serious. The world would not be their oyster without that knowledge. She is a huge talent. Judgments would come from others as they dared to move forward. We knew we needed one another as we attempted to break through these barriers. Judgments would come from others as they dared to move forward and yet, it was managed.
The psychodrama about a conductor facing abuse allegations and her own mental unravelling just picked up six Academy Award nominations, yet hardly anyone ...
[Keva York wrote:](/news/2023-01-24/tar-review-cate-blanchett-todd-field-cancel-culture/101873890) "Although I would argue that Tár is not a polemic but a psychodrama, it's nevertheless true that the film is wilfully enigmatic." [2021 documentary The Conductor](https://www.nytimes.com/2022/01/27/movies/the-conductor-review.html), is name-checked early in Tár and, as [Zachary Woolfe points out in The New York Times](https://www.nytimes.com/2022/10/13/arts/music/tar-female-conductors-power.html), shares many biographical details with fictional Lydia Tár. When it opened in the US in October, [parody social media accounts](https://twitter.com/LydiaTarReal) began to crop up as well as [theories about the film's final act](https://slate.com/culture/2022/12/tar-cate-blanchett-movie-ending-explained-analyzed.html). And when is it no longer a benefit?" So we're able to lean into the complexity of the question." Baard said: "Unlike a big superhero movie or a star-studded romantic comedy, Tár is a film that requires more [commitment and understanding from the average audience]. [ Attitude, saying](https://www.attitude.co.uk/culture/cate-blanchett-on-tar-gaytoo-and-her-lesbian-icon-status-ill-take-it-422529/): "Yeah, baby! If she manages to beat out other Oscars frontrunner Michelle Yeoh (who won the Golden Globe for lead actress in a movie comedy for That includes Tár, which is being released in Australia in sync with the Oscar nominations. She's also barely able to hide her interest in a young cellist (newcomer Sophie Kauer). She describes playing a conductor as "exhilarating and addictive … But power is a very compelling and corruptive force," says Blanchett.
Sophie Kauer on how film and fame won't get in the way of practicing.
Again, gratitude emerges as the overriding emotion: ‘The film pushed me to develop my performing mindset - I don’t think I would have sorted it out that quickly and I think I might have felt a bit stuck if I spent my whole bachelors in a practice room. For the immediate future, she was thrilled that her parents and sister were able to attend the premiere. ‘I’ve always been fascinated by the emotional life of people and had a love of languages - It’s healthy to think of yourself as more than a musician.’ Olga is far from the cellist I know in Kauer, demonstrating her incredible ability to enter into a character’s psyche and not only act, but play the cello in a different mind, shown in the film’s live recording of the Elgar Cello Concerto. ‘I want to show people that musicians’ voices are valid, but part of my being able to do that is I have had to start setting clear boundaries. ‘I really like that they wanted to make the album a snapshot into what it’s like to record, because people often don’t know how it works. Kauer’s contribution to the album includes the fourth movement from Elgar’s Cello Concerto, alongside a section from the first movement and some additional conversations from the recording session. Where is the cello sitting now in spite of such success in acting? Our lives overlapped through learning cello with Melissa Phelps and thinking back to that time, I’ll never forget Kauer aged 15, being so sincere, kind and dedicated to the cello - never failing to tap into the strength and potential of its sound. Kauer shares the excitement with open arms: ‘Do you want to see the dress?’ She opens her phone to show me the Giles Deacon stunning ‘Cynge Gown’ of white cotton with a tulle skirt that she’ll wear on the red carpet. Todd also took me through the backstory, helping me to understand what my character was feeling and why he wrote her the way he did.’ Her white cello case is on the floor next to us, but she decides to prop it up in sight instead.
Conductor Natalie Murray Beale talks to Limelight about teaching Cate Blanchett to wield the baton in TÁR and the film's potential to provoke.
I immediately think of regions, cities or towns where there isn’t a concert hall, or a practising orchestra, and so the possibility of seeing a conductor live is impossible. It’s easy to recognise that playing an instrument or conducting is a very specific skill and in TÁR the camera takes you up close to the performers. The joy I find in working with actors is their incredible skills of listening and reacting, being free with their bodies, spatial awareness, an openness to trying new things. He engaged a real orchestra, the wonderful Dresdner Philharmonie, who play and act in the film. Australian audiences are just about to see TÁR in the cinemas (from 26 January) and there’s a great deal of interest in it, particularly in the music sector. There’s also an immersive quality, you may feel like you are a fly on the wall, observing the action, which brings you very close to the characters and draws you into the music making.
Cate Blanchett's fierce composer is a proxy for all the rage I'm not allowed, as a middle-aged woman, to express.
In the scene when Tár storms the stage to wrest her precious annotated score from the man who has stolen it – a violent scene that is none the less powerful for being (perhaps) a fantasy – I felt a fierce combination of rage and satisfaction course through my body. I gaped enviously at her white shirts and her bespoke suits; the poured concrete of her apartment; the pad across town kept, it is implied, for extra-marital sex; the workaholic tendencies; the naked pride in her talent. Cate Blanchett is the same age as me, and there she was, filling up the screen: taking her place, the opposite of invisible. I understand that she might be; that it’s possible to see her as a fiend. [social media](https://www.newstatesman.com/tag/social-media), men insist Todd Field’s award-winning film – about the fall of a renowned composer and conductor, Lydia Tár, played by Cate Blanchett – is just so much pretentious, culture war dross; in the New York Review of Books, Zadie Smith’s awestruck scene-by-scene anatomisation runs to thousands of words and comes with footnotes. I can’t remember the last time a movie divided opinion as Tár has.
Historic Papple Steading has brought a touch of Hollywood to Haddington, East Lothian, after being taken over by Todd Field to work on Oscar-tipped Tár.
“There’s some provenance in the building and it allows us to begin to tell the story of the laird and the ploughman. That was quite nice for the team, it was a privilege.” She loved the place as well, and thought it was a great post-production place.” The bonus is that Todd and the team liked it so much.” “There had been a throwaway comment about finding a place in the middle of nowhere in Scotland,” he explained. It wasn’t the film’s lead actor, but a star with a very similar name.
It's an, at-times, icy black comedy and a tragic character study melded within the cancel culture mentality and the #MeToo movement. It asks questions and poses ...
Field’s script doesn’t delve too deep into the allegations that follow Tár, with only something of a throwaway suggestion that she “enticed and groomed young women” as our in to this certain narrative strand. In a post-#MeToo landscape, Tár is intelligent enough to not present this storyline as a type-of pat-on-the-back, self-congratulatory additive, but address the very experienced reality that women in power can be just as corrupt and as predatory as the predominant men that such accusations have often followed. It asks questions and poses theories it doesn’t want to finely answer, and whatever it asks with something of certainty – that of “if we’re able to separate the art from the artist?” – it secures that the answer is an impossible demand to even comprehend.
Todd Field wrote and directed Tar with Cate Blanchett in mind for the lead. It tells a tale of misconduct, manipulation, and a power-hungry conductor who ...
The field doesn’t let up for a second, down to the film’s credits, which open with all those who work behind the scenes at the bottom of the movie ‘food chain’ and end with the actors and musicians who usually bask in all the glory. Where visuals offer no moments of warmth or catharsis, the sound design in the film is also impeccable. The most impressive element of the film is Cate Blanchett’s performance. The– entirely fictional– Lydia Tár (Cate Blanchett) is widely regarded to be one of the most successful living composers/conductors of her time and a trailblazer for female conductors. The film is two hours and forty minutes of stunning visuals, gut-clenching tension and scintillating performances. Tár (2022) is set in the intriguing international world of Westen classical music.
Tár is covered in Oscar nominations, and it's clear to see from how Todd Gothic creates a Gothic horror movie about cancel culture.
As she works in her apartment, there is constant knocking at her door, and she is haunted by the sounds of distant chimes ringing in her ear. At one point, in a public park, she is disoriented by the sounds of distant sirens and a woman screaming. She wakes up in the middle of the night to find a metronome ticking in her office, keeping time; she snaps the pendulum off it. Tár is a conductor for the Berlin Philharmonic. At one point, after suggesting something “a little less considered” to the photographer (Artjom Gilz) working on her album art, the film cuts to an even more staged photo of her thoughtfully reviewing and notating her portfolio in the concert hall. “Time is the essential piece of interpretation. Late in the movie, it is revealed that Lydia Tár is herself a fiction. “Time is the thing,” she boasts. It is the tale of somebody with a guilty conscience, desperately hoping that the past won’t catch up to them. Tár is ambiguous about the precise nature of the relationship. She is introduced as a student of the real-life composer Leonard Bernstein, whom she affectionately refers to as “Lenny.” She appears on Here’s the Thing, with Alec Baldwin playing himself. Much of the discussion of Tár has focused on its engagement with the idea of “cancel culture.” Around an hour into the film, it is revealed that one of Tár’s former students, Krista Taylor (Sylvia Flote), has taken her own life.
Lydia Tár is an EGOT, a woman of unparalleled achievements, and one of the greatest living composers in classical music. However, she is not a real person, even ...
Tár is representative of the quintessential anti-heroine character, and she truly is a very unlikable person. Tár also presents a poignant and somewhat comedic ending, and without spoiling, we see Lydia Tár end up in place she probably never thought she would be. She is fantastic and dazzling as the central character, and she seems like the perfect choice to pull off a role like this. There is also a scene where Tár berates a pangender student for not wanting to engage with cisgender composers like Johann Sebastian Bach, stating they should look past the superficial appearances and appreciate the music. The film is a quiet assessment on themes such as identity, hierarchical power structures, cancel culture, and separating the art from the artist. The film ultimately centres on how Tár wields and enacts power, and the consequences this has on her during her downfall.
Following a divisive response from the classical music world about the film “Tár,” the film has been nominated for six Academy Awards including Best Picture ...
I give the film three-and-a-half gold batons out of five.” [Danielle De Niese](https://www.instagram.com/p/CnXZ1U8MNRG/) attended the London premiere and praised the film on social media writing, “GO AND SEE THIS FILM! [Leonard Slatkin](https://www.leonardslatkin.com/un-tar-nished/) also wrote an essay about the film stating, “I was engrossed for the entire length of the film. [discussion](https://operawire.com/marin-alsop-calls-award-winning-film-tar-offensive/) over “Tár” first took light after Marin Alsop noted that she found the film offensive.