Senator Sharon Keogan claims surrogacy is 'harmful, exploitative and unethical'
She told Ms Keogan “you know yourself you have been disrespectful at times over the last number of meetings”. She is part of our lives.” She said Ms Keogan’s comments could be “slightly insulting to me and to my colleagues”. “The current process to allow the father assigned parental rights can take up to five years, depending on where in the country the court proceedings are taking place. Ms Keogan told Mr Kenny Moore, the representative for Irish Gay Dads, “Gearoid, you are extremely lucky to be here today. It has to be a chamber for all views”. You are crude and cold, and it is not OK.” You don’t know how lucky you are to be here today. “Nobody here is trying to whitewash, as you mentioned, people out of the picture. Gearoid Kenny Moore, a representative for Irish Gay Dads, said he was asking for a framework that supports people to make ethical decisions in the interest of child, surrogate and intended parent. Another witness, LGBT Ireland representative Claire O’Connell, said she took issue “with the suggestion that you don’t believe everyone has a right to parent a child. “Surrogacy I believe is harmful, it is exploitative and it is unethical. We are Irish citizens, your constituents, you are our representatives.”
Independent Senator Sharon Keogan was accused of bigotry by Senator Lynn Ruane following comments made towards representatives of those who use international ...
"You're crude and you're cold." "To critically engage with something, you have to be able to understand all sides of it. "It is a privilege to give birth, and it can be dangerous, even to those with medical attention." Ruane accused of Keogan of bigotry, and of being "cold and cruel". "Surrogacy, I believe, is harmful, is exploitative, and is unethical. "I wholeheartedly object to the commercialisation of the human child," Keogan said.
An Oireachtas Committee tasked with examining laws to regulate surrogacy has been suspended after one member was accused of being "crude and cold" towards ...
A number of our members have had experiences of being questioned at passport control," she said. We are their mammies and we are their family. If there was to be a marriage breakup the wife would be left in a very vulnerable position in terms of rights over their children, which could be used against them in an exploitative way. Our children's needs are paramount, they need stability and certainty from the benefit of having two legally recognised parents. "This separation has been extremely distressing for both our members and their children. Mothers cannot travel alone with their children without showing proof from the father to travel abroad.
Committee chair Kathleen Funchion TD was forced to suspend the meeting after comments from Independent Senator Sharon Keogan.
Our families are families, not different.” “I don’t believe it is everyone’s right to have a child. “A big gap in the proposed legislation means there is not a mechanism in law to create a legal parent relationship for children born through surrogacy so that the child has a legal link with both parents. She said that Ireland has an opportunity to be “a world leader” in recognising the rights of children born through surrogacy. The committee heard that proposed legislation to regulate surrogacy in Ireland does not create a mechanism to recognise children as the legal children of both parents. During the meeting, Independent Senator Sharon Keogan said that she “wholeheartedly objects to the commercialisation of the human child” and said that surrogacy was “harmful, exploitative and unethical”.
The Oireachtas committee tasked with examining laws to regulate surrogacy was suspended on Thursday after independent senator Sharon Keogan was accused of being ...
Our members are ordinary people who have, in some cases, been through harrowing experiences. She told committee witness Gearóid Kenny Moore, who, with his husband, had twins through surrogacy, that he was "extremely lucky to be here today". Matters escalated significantly after Ms Keogan said that in her belief surrogacy was "harmful, exploitative and unethical" and "not in the best interest of the child".
An Oireachtas committee on international surrogacy had to be suspended earlier after a row broke out among Senators. Independent Sharon Keogan was accused ...
The chair of the Joint Committee on International Surrogacy has suspended its public meeting after@SenLynnRuaneand @SenatorKeoganclashed over comments Ms Keogan made to witnesses about surrogacy. “A big gap in the proposed legislation means there is not a mechanism in law to create a legal parent relationship for children born through surrogacy so that the child has a legal link with both parents. “This is Ireland’s opportunity to be a world leader, to recognise the diverse and evolving nature of modern families and to legislate appropriately. Appearing before the Oireachtas Joint Committee on International Surrogacy, she said that Ireland has an opportunity to be “a world leader” in recognising the rights of children born through surrogacy. Ciara Merrigan, chair of Irish Families Through Surrogacy, said there is a “big gap” in the current proposed legislation which does not allow for a legal parent-child relationship to be established. During Thursday's hearing, the committee was told that proposed legislation to regulate surrogacy in Ireland does create a mechanism to recognise children as the legal children of both parents.
A senator has been accused of using “inflammatory” and “insulting” language by same sex parents and mothers of children born through surrogacy.
“You’re crude, and you’re cold.” Inflammatory language and using undefined terms don’t benefit the debate,” It is a privilege to give birth, and it can be dangerous even to those with the best medical attention.” “Surrogacy I believe is harmful, it’s exploitative and it’s unethical. Irrespective of whether you’re heterosexual, single, lesbian, gay or trans,” Ms Keogan said. Sharon Keogan, an independent senator, was asked to leave an Oireachtas committee on international surrogacy on Thursday morning following a heated row between politicians.
Senator Sharon Keogan reacted when Senator Lynn Ruane referred to the 'bigotry' of some contributors. The argument escalated when Senator Keogan told Irish Gay ...
Sharon Keogan says a comment she made to representative for Irish Gay Dads was “misinterpreted”.
“During a brief private meeting of the Committee, the acting chair proceeded to warn me that the witnesses could sue me under privilege. I believe that no apology is due because the acting Chair shut me down while I was trying to finish a point which she arbitrarily decided to misinterpret. The meeting was suspended, and I was asked to apologise to a witness.
Str Lynn Ruane and Str Sharon Keogan face off during heated exchange. Proceedings at the Joint Committee on International Surrogacy had to be suspended as ...
No EU member state has legislated specifically for its own citizens engaging in surrogacy in another jurisdiction, the Oireachtas Joint Committee on Surrogacy ...
“How can we possibly ban it here and give it the green light in Ukraine? This sets a complete double standard. “The discomfort the Senator has expressed with surrogacy practices abroad is part of the real complexity of the issue,” he said. “I have great difficulty with the payments involved and I have grave concerns about the commercialisation of children and babies,” she said. The right of a child to know his or her identity and understand the origin of his or her birth is keenly appreciated given the Department’s work on the Birth Information and Tracing Bill, he said. The issue of payments for surrogacy is of particular relevance and significance in the context of international surrogacy. “International commercial surrogacy does raise concerns about the commodification of children, exploitation of women in poorer countries, the risk of child trafficking and the child’s right to know his or her identity,” he said.
After hearing from Gearoid Kenny Moore, a representative for Irish Gay Dads, Senator Lynne Ruane began her address by thanking him as well as other speakers ...
During this global COVID pandemic, we like many other organisations have been impacted greatly in the way we can do business and produce. It is a privilege to give birth and it can be dangerous even to those with the best medical attention.” After issuing a warning that she would suspend the meeting’s chair, Deputy Jennifer Whitmore, formally suspended the proceedings when Senator Keogan turned to Mr Kenny Moore saying “Gearóid you’re extremely lucky to be here today. I don’t believe it is everyone’s right to have a child. She recognised the “huge emotional toll” that sharing their testimonies required. respect, compassion, love”.