All the Old Knives

Loves and loyalties collide in slow-motion for Chris Pine and Thandiwe Newton in this sluggish CIA thriller with promise but no payoff.

Elsewhere, screenwriter (and author of the original novel) Olen Steinhauer could maybe have used some help to help tighten things up, just as director Janus Metz Pedersen is in sore need of an editor to lift the mood. It’s weird to see a male action star play someone their own age for once, and Pine settles into the more seasoned dramatic role well, but Newton outshines him. Walking into a bar that only serves wine to try and order a vodka martini, Henry Pelham (Pine) is a very Chardonnay 007 – colder, sadder and far less exciting than the stuff you see in other movies, though probably a lot more realistic.

All the Old Knives (15A) stars Chris Pine as Henry Pelham, a CIA veteran who travels from Vienna to California to interview his former colleague, ...

The film then uses parallel timelines, cutting between the current conversation between Henry and Celia and extended flashbacks showing what they were doing ...

As espionage narratives go, “All the Old Knives,” which is based on the novel by Olen Steinhauer (who also wrote the screenplay), is closer to the more cerebral and realistic creations of John le Carré than the comic book fantasies of James Bond (underscored perhaps a bit too bluntly at one point where Henry attempts to order a vodka martini and is rebuffed). The early set-up scenes are reasonably intriguing but at a certain point, things just stop working. It soon becomes clear at least one of them knows more about what happened than they are letting on, and that the sumptuous feast they have been consuming will most likely prove to be the last meal for at least one of them. Henry is charged with interviewing the surviving members of the group—one mysteriously committed suicide a couple of months after the incident—to see if he can ferret out which one is guilty.

The year is 2011, and CIA agents Henry (Chris Pine) and Celia (Thandiwe Newton) are colleagues and lovers. But one fateful day, a terrible (fictional) terrorist ...

Plot twist: Celia tells Henry she knows he was the one who made the call on Bill’s phone, and that he is the mole who leaked the information about Ahmed to the terrorists. In the final scene, we see Vick get a call letting him know that Henry is dead, while Celia walks down the street, thinking about her past relationship with Henry. Then she goes home to her husband and child and goes back to her life. Remember that weird meeting Celia had with the Muslim Women’s Foundation? It turns out that while Celia was at that meeting, Henry was at a meeting of his own, with Ilyas Shishani, the man behind the attack. Then Henry gets a call from the assassin he hired, asking whether or not he should kill Celia. Henry is too far gone to answer, so in the end, the assassin does not kill Celia—but we’re left wondering what he would have said. Celia is devastated that Henry would try to pin this on her, and ruin her life when he knows she is innocent. At the same time, Henry seems to be ready to pin the leak on his aging colleague Bill Compton. After all, it was Bill’s phone that had a call to Tehran on the same day as the attack, and Bill does act pretty suspicious when Henry is interviewing him. In the flashbacks, we learn that on the day of the attack, Celia discovered the suspicious call to Tehran made from Bill’s phone on the call log. Read on for the All the Old Knives plot summary and the All the Old Knives ending, explained. At the end of this day horrible day, Henry and Celia share a desperate, passionate night together. In the present day, Celia tells Henry she doesn’t believe the man had information, and just wanted money—but Henry’s reaction suggests he knows something she doesn’t. Vick, the boss, stresses that no one else can know about Ahmed. Later, when Ahmed sends a new message to the CIA telling the agency to comply with all of the terrorists’ demands—in a completely different tone of voice—they suspect that the message is not really from him. Based on the novel of the same name by Olen Steinhauer—who also adapted the screenplay—All the Old Knives is a quiet spy thriller directed by Danish filmmaker Janus Metz Pedersen. Most of the film is spent over the course of a dinner between Pine and Newton’s characters, as the two recall a traumatic day in their past lives as CIA agents and lovers.

The puzzle-box mystery of the new Prime Video spy thriller is reminiscent of Westworld... but the actress likes the more streamlined nature of film.

But I love these kinds of movies where it's placed in an environment, in a situation, that is actually familiar to us now." "It's a tricky film to make in some ways because people aren't necessarily primed for these love stories anymore," Newton says. "I do prefer film because there's an intensity and a need to complete the story in an hour and a half," Newton says.